SAIL-led Indian consortium’s bid for Hajigak iron ore did not comply with bid conditions, and the consortium should have been disqualified from participating in the Hajigak tender, it has been claimed.
Officials in ACATCO, LLC, which participated in the bid for Hajigak iron ore, have said that the bid documents required bidders to submit a detailed technical plan. However, the SAIL-led Indian consortium’s bid lacked this essential requirement.
The officials further added that bid documents required bidders to submit an irrevocable financial plan that assures that the bidder has access to sufficient funds to implement its technical plan. But the Indian consortium did not include this critical information.
“In fact, immediately after being—incorrectly—declared winner of the bid, the SAIL-led consortium publicly announced that it had not secured the funds for its proposal and that securing the required funds from the financial markets would be impossible as Afghanistan was “on the negative list” of private financial institutions,” the officials said.
The officials also added that the Indian consortium had structured its royalty-payment formula in such a way that it violated bid conditions, and would make it impossible for the Afghan government ever to collect royalty.
“Former Minister Shahrani’s declaration that the Indian consortium won the Hajigak tender ignored these obvious deficiencies of the consortium’s bid,” the officials said, adding that the Ministry of Mines and Petroleum would still entertain working with the Indian consortium is beyond comprehension and a matter worthy of investigation.
Nasir Shansab, writing on behalf of ACATCO, said numerous complaints with various government authorities have been filed and those complaints are still pending.
“ACATCO’s bid is the only one that correctly follows all bid conditions. Despite the three-year delay, we have kept our proposal valid. During my last visit to Kabul, I discussed this matter with a number of government officials, including HE Mohammad Akbar Barekzai, the present Minister of Mines and Petroleum. Minister Barekzai asked me to once again present our proposal to the ministry,” Shansab said.
He insisted that Afghanistan must attain financial self-sufficiency if it wishes to be able to act as a sovereign country. “To reach financial self-sufficiency, however, the Afghan government must convince private investors and financial institutions that it can be relied upon to strictly follow the country’s laws and regulations. It is sad that dishonest actions, such as the decisions of ex-Minister Shahrani and his advisers in the Hajigak case, will destroy Afghanistan’s ability to attract foreign private investment,” said Shansab.




